Trust Ranked 39th

Magid just asked 2,000 weekly news consumers to describe 155 news brands using 44 emotional attributes.

“Trustworthy” ranked 39th. Eight percent.

Not declining. Not eroding. Irrelevant as a descriptor.

The word we built careers around is no longer the word consumers use when they talk about us.

Trust didn’t fall. Trust got redefined. And while legacy media kept speaking the old language, consumers wrote a new one.

The attributes that now correlate most strongly with perceived quality in news brands, according to Magid’s Omnimedia Landscape study: Contextual. Insightful. Thoughtful. Reassuring. Calming.

The attributes with zero correlation to quality: Balanced. Essential. Substantive. Accurate. Reliable. Trustworthy. Clear.

Every word on the second list was once a compliment in a newsroom. Now they’re noise.

Magid has been consulting for TV newsrooms for decades. They helped build local news as we know it — the formats, the framing, the playbook we all inherited.

Now they’re telling us the playbook is obsolete.

When the architects say the building doesn’t work anymore, you listen.

We kept grading ourselves on a rubric the audience had stopped using. Accurate. Balanced. Essential. We spent a decade defending those standards while consumers quietly replaced them.

Magid’s own conclusion: consumers have filled the void with their own definition of trust. Depth. Confirmation. Reassurance. And yes — bias. Not because people want to be lied to. Because they want to feel oriented in something that makes sense to them.

The consultancy that helped define “balanced” and “accurate” as the gold standard is now telling us those words have zero correlation with quality.

And who ranks #3 on Magid’s Trust Index? Aaron Parnas — an independent journalist and attorney who explains news in real-time. He’s above NPR, PBS NewsHour, BBC, and Reuters.

He’s not more credible. He’s more present.

The DTC beauty category is crowded. To break through, Jennifer Aniston’s brand LolaVie, worked with Roku Ads Manager to easily set up, test, and optimize CTV ad creatives. The campaign helped drive a big lift in sales and customer growth, helping LolaVie break through in the crowded beauty category.

Learn more

Magid asked which brands feel most “community-connected.”

The top ten: Candace Owens. Al Jazeera. Meidas Touch. Steven Crowder. ProPublica. Rachel Maddow. John Oliver. Jesse Watters. Brian Tyler Cohen. Nick Shirley.

Most local brands landed in the bottom half.

Community is now psychographic, political, moral, and cultural. Not where you live.

That finding should stop every local news executive in their tracks. “Hyperlocal” as a strategy assumed community was geographic. The audience has told us, plainly, that it isn’t anymore.

Local newspapers rank #1 on “essential.” Local TV stations dominate the top of that list. Thirty to forty percent of users call these sources essential.

And essential has zero correlation to trust, intentionality, evaluation, or usage.

Being considered important does not translate into anyone actually using you. This is the gap between “we still matter” and “we’re still losing.”

I spent over 20 years running newsrooms on the assumption that if we were accurate, balanced, and essential, trust would follow. Those were the words we used to describe good journalism. Those were the words we trained young producers and reporters to embody.

None of them move the needle anymore.

I was using a language the audience had already stopped using.

Magid calls it the end of the Breaking News Era and the start of the Context Era.

Speed used to be the flex. Now the flex is meaning. Consumers aren’t asking us to be first. They’re asking us to help them understand what to do with what they already know.

The difference looks like this:

𝗕𝗿𝗲𝗮𝗸𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗡𝗲𝘄𝘀 𝗘𝗿𝗮: “City council votes to cut transit funding.”

𝗖𝗼𝗻𝘁𝗲𝘅𝘁 𝗘𝗿𝗮: “Here’s what the transit vote actually means for your commute — and why this fight has been building for three years.”

One tells you what happened. The other helps you understand why it matters to your life.

That is a completely different product. And most legacy newsrooms are still optimizing for the old one.

To news executives: if “trustworthy” is the 39th word your audience uses to describe your brand, what word is first — and does it make you proud?

To news directors: what do you teach your reporters to be that the audience no longer values?

To working journalists: if community has stopped being geographic, what community are you actually serving?